As we have experienced, Lewis creates transitivity to your causation from the identifying causation with regards to chains from causal dependency

dos.2 Transitivity

Yet not, enough alleged counter-examples was basically presented hence throw question towards transitivity. (Lewis 2004a gifts a preliminary catalog of them counterexamples.) We have found an example regarding two counterexamples.

Very first, a keen unpublished however, much-discussed example on account of Ned Hallway. Good hiker try taking walks along a mountain walk, when good boulder large significantly more than try dislodged and you may happens careering down the mountain hills. New hiker observes the new boulder and you can ducks during the compatible time. The fresh new careering boulder reasons the hiker so you’re able to duck which, in turn, explanations his proceeded stride. (It second causal connect pertains to double avoidance: the brand new duck inhibits new accident ranging from hiker and boulder and that, got they happened, would have prevented the hikers continued stride.) But not, the newest careering boulder ‘s the types of thing who generally avoid the hikers continued stride and therefore it appears to be counterintuitive so you’re able to declare that they causes this new hookup bars near me Hollywood stride. Daha fazlasını oku